Blog

Ecommerce checkout optimization: find the step losing orders and fix it in the right order

Ecommerce checkout fixes in the right order: find the leaking step, cut fields, add wallets, see Shopify's limits by plan and prepare for agent checkout.

By Rokibul Hasan8 min read

  • E-commerce
  • Checkout
A laptop screen showing an online order summary with a green checkout button.

Most advice on the ecommerce checkout arrives as a list of forty tips with no order to them. A store owner can spend a month changing button colours while the real cause, usually a delivery charge nobody saw coming, stays exactly where it was.

This guide is for owners of small and mid-sized stores on Shopify, WooCommerce or a custom site. It shows how to find the step that is losing orders, which fix matches which cause, what Shopify lets you change on each plan as of November 2026, and what AI agents buying for a shopper will need from your checkout.

The research below comes from Baymard Institute's own pages. The reading of it is mine: I am a developer, and I do not run a store.

Find the leaking step in your ecommerce checkout

Baymard puts average cart abandonment at 70.22%, calculated from 50 studies. That number says nothing about where your own checkout fails, and plenty of those shoppers were never going to buy.

What you need is a funnel by step, split by mobile and desktop. On Shopify the standard web pixel events map the steps for you: checkout_started, checkout_contact_info_submitted, checkout_address_info_submitted, checkout_shipping_info_submitted, payment_info_submitted and checkout_completed. On WooCommerce or a custom site, send equivalent events to your analytics tool.

Then read the biggest drop like this:

Biggest drop after Likely cause Check first
Cart Costs not visible, or browsing Is a delivery estimate shown in the cart?
Contact step Account wall Is guest checkout the obvious path?
Address step Form length, mobile typing Field count, autofill, keyboards
Delivery step Price or date seen for the first time Delivery prices and dates
Payment step Missing method, declines, doubt Decline rate, wallets offered

Look at four weeks or more. A store with a few hundred checkouts a month cannot run a reliable A/B test on a small change, so fix what the funnel and the research both point to. The arithmetic is in my post on ecommerce personalisation.

What shoppers say drove them away

Baymard asks US shoppers why they abandoned. Leaving aside the 42% who were just browsing, these are the reasons on its list, matched with the fix I would try for each:

Reason given Share Fix to try
Extra costs too high 40% Show delivery and tax in the cart, set a clear free delivery threshold
Delivery too slow 20% Show a date per option, offer a faster service
Did not trust the site with card details 19% Wallets, a plain payment page
Site wanted an account 18% Guest first, offer an account after purchase
Too long or complicated 17% Fewer fields
Errors or crashes 17% Test real orders, remove scripts
Returns policy 13% One-line returns summary in checkout
Total not visible up front 12% Running total on every step
Card declined 10% Keep the form filled, offer another method
Not enough payment methods 9% Add the wallets your customers use

Two cautions. The shares add up to well over 100%, so people gave several reasons, and they are self-reports from US shoppers. Baymard also estimates that better checkout design could raise conversion by 35.26%, but that is an average for large sites and covers only issues it judged fixable. Treat it as evidence that gains exist, not as a forecast for your store.

Cost and delivery speed lead the table, and both are commercial decisions. No form redesign rescues a delivery charge that appears on step three.

Cut the ecommerce checkout form: a worked example

Baymard's checkout guide, updated on 2 November 2026, says the average checkout has 19.9 form elements while an optimised flow can be as short as 12. Its June 2024 research says most sites need only 8 form fields, and that step count matters less than the number of fields people must manage. Here is what that means for a typical form:

  • Confirm email. Remove it and check the format inline.
  • First and last name. On a custom site, use one field: Baymard found 89% of sites have more than one. Shopify offers "Only require last name" or first and last name, so the choice there is smaller.
  • Company. On Shopify, set it to "Don't include" unless you sell to businesses. If it is Required, Apple Pay and Google Pay shoppers whose wallet holds no company name have to type one in.
  • Address line 2. Baymard saw 30% of test participants stop at this field and recommends hiding it behind a link. On Shopify leave it Optional, because Shopify warns that Required or "Don't include" can stop some customers proceeding.
  • Phone. Optional, unless your carrier or payment provider needs it.
  • Billing address. Default to "same as shipping". Baymard says this alone can cut visible fields by 30% to 40%.
  • Coupon. Tuck it behind a link. Baymard reports that 35% of sites with the field show it by default, and a visible box sends people off to search for a code.
  • Password. Ask after the order, never before. Baymard says 62% of sites do not make guest checkout the most prominent option.

That leaves seven fields before payment: email, full name, address, city, state or county, postcode and country.

On a custom site, set autocomplete values such as email, name and postal-code so browsers can fill the form, and use the right mobile keyboard for each field. Then fix errors: Baymard says 98% of sites do not give specific, plain error messages, 31% have no inline validation and 34% do not keep card details after an error, which forces people to retype them.

Wallets: fewer fields without redesigning anything

A wallet removes typing altogether. On Shopify, accelerated checkouts cover Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Amazon Pay and PayPal. Baymard's advice is to offer several methods but keep the choice simple.

Test each button on a real phone. The fee side of this decision is in my guide to ecommerce payments.

Speed, scripts and a tracking trap

On a custom checkout, Google's Core Web Vitals give sensible targets: main content within 2.5 seconds, a response to input within 200 milliseconds and layout shift of 0.1 or less, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads. Each third-party tag on a payment page is also a security question.

Shopify hosts its checkout, so speed is largely not yours to tune. But there is a trap if your conversion numbers moved this year. Script tags stopped running on the Order status page for Plus stores on 28 August 2025 and for all other stores on 26 August 2026. If a tracking tag lived there, an apparent fall in conversions may be a reporting gap, so compare your analytics against actual orders before you redesign anything.

What Shopify lets you change, by plan

Shopify's pricing page calls checkout customisation "Limited" on Basic, Grow and Advanced, with full customisation on Plus. In practice, checked in November 2026:

What you want Basic to Advanced Plus
Logo, colours and fonts in the editor Yes Yes
Form field settings above Yes Yes
Apps on thank you and order status pages Yes Yes
Apps on information, shipping and payment steps No Yes
Checkout Branding API No Yes
Public apps using Shopify Functions Yes Yes
Custom apps using Shopify Functions No Yes
Rename or reorder card options (US, Canada) No Yes

Shopify's developer docs exclude the Starter plan from most of this, and Checkout Blocks works below Plus with some feature restrictions. Checkout UI extensions run in a sandbox with no access to the page itself, and bundles cannot exceed 64 KB, even on Plus.

Plus starts at $2,300 a month on monthly billing. Almost everything in this post is a free setting, so do not upgrade for a checkout tweak until those are done. On WooCommerce or a custom store you can change everything, and you also own every bug; the trade-off is in Shopify vs a custom website.

Agent checkout is next, and it wants the same things

Two October 2026 launches put agents next to your checkout. On 15 October, Google's Universal Cart reached US shoppers, who can pay with Google Pay in the cart at many stores or move the items to the merchant's own cart, with the merchant staying seller of record. On 28 October, Shopify's Fall '26 Edition said WebMCP tools on every Liquid and Hydrogen storefront and checkout let browser agents "complete checkout once the buyer approves".

My reading is that an agent trips on the same faults a person does: a charge that appears late, a delivery date nobody published, a vague returns policy. A required custom field that only a human can answer could stop it altogether, so review any you have added. The practical detail is in Google Universal Cart for merchants and WebMCP for online stores.

FAQ

What is a good ecommerce checkout abandonment rate?

There is no reliable target for an individual store. Baymard's average across 50 studies is about 70%, but that figure mixes industries, devices and methods, and it includes people who were only browsing. A more useful measure is your own completion rate per checkout step, tracked over time and split by mobile and desktop. If one step loses far more people than the others, start there.

Is a one-page checkout better than a multi-step checkout?

Not automatically. Baymard's research found that the number of steps has less effect on checkout performance than the total number of form fields people must deal with, and its 2024 benchmark put the average flow at 5.1 steps. A long single page can feel heavier than three short steps. Cut the fields first, show progress clearly and keep the order total visible throughout, then decide on layout.

Do I need Shopify Plus to improve my checkout?

No. Field settings, branding, wallets, address autocompletion and delivery pricing are all available on Basic and above, and those are where most of the gains sit. Plus becomes necessary when you need apps on the information, shipping or payment steps, the Checkout Branding API, or custom apps using Shopify Functions. Work through the free settings first and measure them before paying for an upgrade.

If your checkout needs something the settings cannot do, send me a short brief: your platform and plan, your step-by-step drop-off figures, and the one change you want. A single focused checkout feature is the kind of work the Shopify app MVP plan covers, from $2,000 as a starting price with a fixed quote after the brief. See Shopify app development, or read how agentic commerce is changing what stores need to prepare.