Blog

Ecommerce payments: choosing and integrating gateways, wallets and BNPL without surprises

Ecommerce payments compared on one $80 order: Stripe, PayPal, Shopify and Square fees, BNPL costs, PCI scope by integration type and payout reconciliation.

By Rokibul Hasan8 min read

  • E-commerce
  • Payments
A customer tapping a card on a small card reader held by a merchant.

Choosing how to take ecommerce payments usually happens once, in a hurry, the week a store launches. The headline rate gets compared and the rest waits: how the card form reaches the page, what that does to your PCI obligations, and how a payout gets matched to its orders. Those are the parts that cost money after launch.

This guide is for store owners and their developers, on Shopify, WooCommerce or a custom site. It compares published fees on one worked order, explains PCI scope by integration method, and covers the details that fail quietly.

All fees below were read on each provider's official pricing page in November 2026. They are US rates unless stated, and they change, so check the page for your own country. I am a developer, not a Qualified Security Assessor, so confirm the PCI section with your acquirer.

Four roles that people mix up

A gateway carries card details securely from the checkout to the bank side, a processor moves the transaction through the card networks, and an acquirer is the bank holding the merchant relationship. Stripe, PayPal, Square and Shopify Payments bundle these into one account. Wallets such as Apple Pay sit on top of cards, so the shopper skips typing. Buy now, pay later (BNPL) providers pay you up front and collect instalments from the shopper, for a higher fee.

Ecommerce payments compared: what an $80 order costs

Method Published rate Fee on $80
Shopify Payments, Basic 2.9% + 30¢ $2.62
Shopify Payments, Grow 2.7% + 30¢ $2.46
Shopify Payments, Advanced 2.5% + 30¢ $2.30
Stripe, cards and wallets 2.9% + 30¢ $2.62
Square online, Free plan 3.3% + 30¢ $2.94
Square online, paid plans 2.9% + 30¢ $2.62
PayPal, standard cards 2.99% + 49¢ $2.88
PayPal, advanced cards 2.89% + 29¢ $2.60
PayPal Checkout 3.49% + 49¢ $3.28

Sources: Stripe, PayPal (fee page last updated 1 October 2026), Square and Shopify. WooPayments lists the same 2.9% + 30¢ base rate on its fees page.

The extras are where rates separate:

  • International cards. Stripe and PayPal add 1.5%; Shopify adds 1%.
  • Currency conversion. Stripe adds 1% when conversion is needed.
  • Premium cards. Shopify charges 3.5% + 30¢ on Basic for business cards and all domestic American Express cards.
  • UK rates differ a lot. Stripe's UK page lists 1.5% + 20p for standard UK cards, 2.5% + 20p for EEA cards and 3.15% + 20p for international cards.

Flat rates are not the only model. Adyen publishes interchange-plus pricing, shown as $0.13 plus interchange plus 0.60% for Visa and Mastercard, and says a minimum invoice may apply. That model tends to suit high volume.

The Shopify arithmetic most people skip

If you use another provider on Shopify, Shopify adds a third-party transaction fee on top of that provider's charge: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. On an $80 order on Basic, that is another $1.60. PayPal is exempt when Shopify Payments is your primary provider, and if you run Shopify Payments alongside a third-party provider, Shopify Payments transactions are charged at standard rates "plus a 1.25% premium".

Card rates also change the plan decision. Moving from Basic to Grow saves 16¢ on each $80 order and costs $66 more a month on monthly billing in the US ($39 to $105), so card fees alone pay for it at about 413 orders a month. That sum assumes every order is a domestic standard card, so run it on your own mix.

BNPL: same product, different prices

Published merchant rates for instalments vary widely by route:

Route Published US rate Fee on $80
PayPal Pay Later 4.99% + 49¢ $4.48
Klarna through Stripe 5.99% + 30¢ $5.09

Adyen lists Klarna in the US at $0.13 + 4.29% + $0.30. Shop Pay Installments varies by country, so check your admin.

Adobe's forecast, reported by Digital Commerce 360 on 29 September 2026, puts BNPL at $21.3 billion of US online holiday spending, up 6.6%, so some customers will look for it. Judge it on margin. If an $80 order earns $24 gross, Klarna through Stripe costs $2.47 more than a card, about a tenth of that margin. It pays only where it lifts order value or conversion, so measure it for a season.

PCI scope depends on how the card form reaches the page

Every business that accepts cards has PCI DSS obligations, and Stripe says you must attest to compliance annually. What changes is how much of the standard applies, which follows from where the card fields come from.

How cards are collected Usual questionnaire What it means
Redirect to a provider's hosted page SAQ A Smallest scope; your site never touches the form
Provider's fields embedded in your page, such as Stripe Elements SAQ A, with a script condition You must confirm the page is protected against script attacks
Your page delivers part of the payment form SAQ A-EP Much larger; your web server is in scope
Card numbers pass through your server SAQ D The full standard

That mapping follows Stripe's guide, which lists Checkout and Elements as SAQ A and direct API use as SAQ D. Stripe warns that handling card data directly can mean more than 300 security controls. Your acquirer or the card brands decide which form applies.

The script condition is easy to miss. The PCI Security Standards Council revised SAQ A in January 2025, removing requirements 6.4.3 and 11.6.1 and adding an eligibility criterion: the merchant has confirmed its site is not susceptible to attacks from scripts. The Council's notice of 28 February 2025 says this applies to pages embedding a provider's form, such as an iframe, and not to redirects. You can meet it with techniques like those in the removed requirements, or with confirmation from your PCI compliant provider that its solution protects the page when used as instructed. Check the current form before relying on this, since these documents are revised.

On Shopify the position is simpler. Shopify says it is certified Level 1 and that this "extends by default to all stores powered by Shopify", covering the store, cart and hosting.

My advice for almost any small store: use a hosted or embedded form, never let a card number reach your server or logs, and keep tag managers off the payment page.

UK and EU: plan for authentication

Under Strong Customer Authentication rules, card payments in the UK and EEA generally need 3D Secure, and Stripe warns that banks may decline payments that skip it. A successfully authenticated payment generally moves fraud liability to the card issuer, though Stripe says that is not guaranteed. Test a card that triggers the challenge step.

Integration checks that fail quietly

The examples here come from Stripe's webhook documentation; the ideas apply elsewhere.

  1. Trust the webhook, not the browser. A shopper can close the tab after paying, so confirm the order from the provider's event.
  2. Verify signatures. Check the Stripe-Signature header against the raw request body, or anyone can post you a fake "paid" event.
  3. Expect duplicates and disorder. Stripe says it does not guarantee event order and that endpoints may receive an event twice. Store event IDs and ignore repeats.
  4. Reply first, work later. Return a 2xx quickly and process through a queue.
  5. Save the provider's payment ID on the order, and send your order number as metadata.
  6. Test the unhappy paths: declines, authentication failures, partial refunds and disputes.

Stripe does not return original processing fees on refunds. It charges $15 per dispute, plus $15 if you respond manually, with that second fee refunded only if you win. PayPal lists a $20 chargeback fee and a $15 dispute fee, or $30 at high volume.

Reconciliation: match each payout, not each day

Ecommerce payments arrive net of fees, refunds and disputes, in batches that do not line up with your order dates.

  • Stripe. The itemised payout reconciliation report lists every payment, refund, dispute and fee in a payout, and can include your metadata. It is available with automatic payouts.
  • PayPal. The Transaction Search API can take up to three hours to show a transaction and accepts at most 31 days per request, so a nightly sync should look back a few days.

Posting this to QuickBooks or Xero is covered in ecommerce accounting automation, and the shopper's side of payment choice in ecommerce checkout optimization.

Which setup to start with

Your situation Start with Why
Shopify, in a supported country Shopify Payments plus PayPal No third-party fee, nothing to integrate
WooCommerce or custom, low volume Stripe's hosted Checkout Smallest PCI scope, fast to build
Custom site keeping shoppers on your page Embedded fields Keeps SAQ A, with the script condition
High volume, several countries Quotes for interchange-plus Blended rates become expensive

FAQ

Do I still need PCI compliance if I use Stripe or Shopify?

Yes, in the sense that PCI DSS applies to anyone accepting cards, though the work can be small. Stripe says businesses must attest annually, and hosted or embedded forms usually mean SAQ A, the shortest questionnaire. Shopify says its Level 1 certification extends by default to stores on its platform. Your acquirer decides what you must submit, so confirm it with them.

Should I offer PayPal as well as cards?

Usually, if your customers use it. Baymard Institute reports that 9% of US online shoppers have abandoned a checkout because their preferred payment method was missing. The trade-off is a higher fee: PayPal Checkout costs $3.28 on an $80 order against $2.62 at Stripe's standard card rate. On Shopify, PayPal is exempt from third-party fees when Shopify Payments is your primary provider.

Why do my ecommerce payments cost more than the advertised rate?

Mostly because of the fixed fee and the card mix. At 2.9% + 30¢ a $20 order pays 88¢, which is 4.4%, not 2.9%. International cards, currency conversion, premium and American Express cards, disputes and third-party platform fees all add more. Divide total processing charges by total card sales for a recent month to get your effective rate, then compare providers using that figure and your real order values.

If you need payments connected to a custom site or your back office, send me a short brief: your platform, countries, monthly orders, average order value and current provider. A payout export into your accounting software is the kind of single automation the marketplace MVP plan covers, from $2,500 as a starting price with a fixed quote after the brief; other payment integration is custom work quoted from the brief. See API and backend development, what to automate first or the wider ecommerce tech stack.